CDR Salamander

Share this post

Check Your Magazine Inventory Recently?

cdrsalamander.substack.com

Discover more from CDR Salamander

National security, maritime challenges, naval issues with a flavoring of other things I find interesting.
Over 6,000 subscribers
Continue reading
Sign in

Check Your Magazine Inventory Recently?

missile>bomb>shell>bullet>blade>club>fist>teeth

CDR Salamander
Jul 11, 2022
11
Share this post

Check Your Magazine Inventory Recently?

cdrsalamander.substack.com
7
Share

Some warning will only be given so many times.

We were warned a few months in to the 2003 invasion of Iraq.

We were warned again five years later when we were trying to source what was needed to support the uplift in forces in Afghanistan while Iraq still had high demands. 

Our allies pretty much went Winchester in the 2011 operations against Libya.

We can barely partially source small and medium sized conflicts ... we are not ready for a larger one.

That is a simple fact that seems too painful for people to clearly look at. 

Like the US Navy excels in damage control by design and training, in theory the US military writ large excels in logistics.

What good is the culture and practice if you lack the inventory to move, the production to create ... and even if you did, the strategic sealift and airlift to bring the weapons to the fight?

In peace and in bushwars you can get by with shortages as you can always scrounge around to fill gaps (I have fun stories from AFG, but maybe later), but in a great conflict - there is no untapped resource. You either have it or you don't.

At peace, "experts" will sell you comfortable theories about "short, decisive wars" and "72-hr war-winning CONOPS" that never pan out once the first ITL button is pressed. 

Over at FT, John Paul Rathbone and Steff Chavaz join the chorus trying to wake everyone up;

In May, when Washington ordered 1,300 Stinger anti-air missiles to replace those sent to Ukraine, the chief executive of Raytheon, the defence company that makes them, replied: “It’s going to take us a little bit of time.”

Paris, meanwhile, has sent 18 Caesar howitzers to Kyiv — a quarter of its total stock of the high-tech artillery — but it will take French company Nexter around 18 months to make new ones.

The Ukraine war has exposed the skimpiness of western defence stockpiles — especially of unglamorous but crucial supplies such as artillery shells that have been the mainstay of fighting. Lack of production capacity, labour shortages and supply chain snafus — especially computer chips — mean long lead times to replenish them.

The shortages, defence officials and analysts say, reveal the west’s complacency about potential threats since the end of the cold war, now shown up by the desire to shore up Ukraine with military support. Fetishes for high-tech weaponry and lean manufacturing have obscured the importance of maintaining stockpiles of basic kit, they add.

...

“It’s like the first world war’s great shell crisis,” said Shea, recalling a 1915 scandal when massive artillery use in trench warfare depleted British stocks, a shortage that led to high troop casualties and the resignation of prime minister HH Asquith.

Ponder this as well. The maritime domain has not been as tested as the land component the last few decades. As such, we can assume that our magazine inventory is even more "exquisitely" designed. 

In closed door sessions, I hope that Congress is demanding answers and hard numbers in this area ... and then will fund to fix them.

Leave a comment

Share

11
Share this post

Check Your Magazine Inventory Recently?

cdrsalamander.substack.com
7
Share
7 Comments
Share this discussion

Check Your Magazine Inventory Recently?

cdrsalamander.substack.com
Ambien
Jul 11, 2022

I think the issue with this article is that it doesn't clearly enough outline what war you imagine as the threat.

1) Large wars between major powers will have nuclear weapons at play; there is every reason to believe that they will be 72 hour wars.

2) Wars like Ukraine don't involve mass industrial mobilization so you shouldn't expect weapons to be producible in large quantities on short notice.

Expand full comment
Reply
Share
2 replies
John Weisman
Jul 11, 2022

POTUS needs to use the War Powers Act to replenish inventory. But POTUS is no FDR or HST so he'll find a way to make things worse not better.

Expand full comment
Reply
Share
5 more comments...
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 CDR Salamander
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing