89 Comments
User's avatar
M. Thompson's avatar

I saw GARBALDI in Mayport as a boy. The Italians have a strong maritime tradition, and their ships are built around the theater they expect to operate in. Long term Naval buys including spares and training need to be part of the baseline.

Jon's avatar

An excellent plan. I have a bridge at Messina to sell you instead. :-(

Andy's avatar

Their Fremm and PPA are top notch and the fact that each is headed toward a beefed up flight II. I also like the Centauro II for the Marines should they ever see a need for their own mobile protected firepower.

Jon's avatar

The PPA suffers a bit from fitted for but not with, but after refit they'll have 4 in full configuration and three in light plus configuration. They need to build the other 9 and resist the urge to build European patrol corvettes.

Mattis2024's avatar

They can teach the Brits a thing or two about designing a Navy.

Brettbaker's avatar

The British admit it's a good thing Mussolini didn't have any oil, or the North African/Mediterranean campaigns would not have gone as good as they did.

The Drill SGT's avatar

and it's a great thing the Brits had Adm Cunningham

Doctor Weasel's avatar

He had oil in Libya but didn't know it., as oil was discovered in the 1950s. Given oil, Italy might have owned the Med.

Ron Snyder's avatar

They could also teach us.

Mattis2024's avatar

They tried and we proved we are incapable of learning.

SEE Wisconsin.

Ron Snyder's avatar

Sadly. And we keep the same people in power.

Mattis2024's avatar

Yes because we are sadist who enjoy self inflicted shotgun wounds.

Andy's avatar

There is always an apples to oranges comparison to be made there. Their own ships are decent for the Euro gear they have to equip them with. Our gear was going to require a different ship. The rest is politics.

Ron Snyder's avatar

Not quite. The intent was to build the FREMM pretty much as is, learn the changes we needed to make on future builds. Make as few changes as possible, only absolutely critical changes. Not make all the changes we wanted as the ship was being built. The objective was to deploy a hull in the water ASAP for our Navy, rather than building the first one to meet all U.S. Navy specifications.

Mattis2024's avatar

Sorry but they also tried to help with the Little Crappy Ship which was full of US Crap instead of Euro Crap.

Carl's avatar

It was sold by the US Navy has having an 85% compatibility with existing FREMM builds to save costs. That has been whittled own to 15% with the resulting 50% cost increase and 3 years delay. This design as we build nonsense was major part of the problems with LCS, Zumwalt and yes, the Ford.

Instead of going to the builder withe set design and proven tech NAVSEA, and their inability to learn from past mistakes, keeps repeating them.

Mattis2024's avatar

Hope they can teach the Brits how to maintain one.

William Joseph Downey's avatar

Great article. Even during World War II, Italy had some well-built and capable naval assets. Italy also produced some of the best ocean liners before and following the war.

Concerning Italy's financial contribution to NATO, friends tell me that the revived bridge to Sicily will be pitched as a strategic necessity.

Tom's avatar

Yep. The Italian army was badly equipped, badly led, and badly organized, but everyone respected their air force and navy.

Jetcal1's avatar

The air force was quite good until about 1938. The Spanish Civil and the little Ethiopian foray essentially bankrupted the country. It put them about 4 years behind in fighter development and a decade with their bombers. The corps of experienced pilots was also pretty much gone by mid-'42.

Then of course my favorite Italian politician's airplane the Breda Lince.

https://youtu.be/icK_p2GFDB0?si=W9FriQa3leUZDAid

Pete's avatar

The Greeks put up a good fight against Mussolini, too.

Scoobs's avatar

Probably so the Mafia can get their merchandise to the mainland (old XO of mine was CO of Sigonella during this boondoggle): https://www.military.com/daily-news/2016/07/12/italian-police-raided-navy-commissary-because-exchange-closed.html?amp

Mattis2024's avatar

We will be seeing a-lot of interesting strategic “NATO” projects coming out of the EU. The accounting gimmicks to get to 5% will be laughable.

The Drill SGT's avatar

How about some SOSUS in Sicily?

JH's avatar

Great post. My only question is, what is the state of the Italian Coast Guard, which should also have a signficant role in patrolling seas in and around the Italian Peninsula and supplementing the Navy's role in North Africa.

Andy's avatar

Slightly different roles where the navy has a lot of patrol ships. That said, its still a little thin looking compared to our own.

Mattis2024's avatar

Everyone’s except West Taiwans Coast Guard is thin compared to USCG.

Hell USCG has a larger air force than most NATO members.

Andy's avatar

California has a larger air force than some NATO members.

JH's avatar

Can we talk about where Canada lies on this grid? Ye gods. I knew it was bad, but this is absurd.

M. Thompson's avatar

Trudeau-ism (both pere and fils) means Canada cares little about it's own defense, and stays under the Bald Eagle's talons while tweaking his feathers.

JH's avatar

A country that cannot defend its claims is not sovereign.

M. Thompson's avatar

Yes. I am merely pointing out what has happened over the prior 6 decades.

Mattis2024's avatar

Why? I wouldn’t expect a State to be on it.

M. Thompson's avatar

Even the most left wing states muster more effective National Guards than the Canadians.

Nurse Jane's avatar

Good Afternoon CDR Salamander!

NATO has a good chance in Italy vs Brussels.

Italy should contribute the five (5) percent of Gross Domestic Product.

Pay to Play!

No excuses on what they can or cannot afford.

Set the tariff at 30% for wine, cheese, designer clothing, accessories and furniture imported into the USA.

Italy has a fantastic coastline!

Italy has a Rail Road to its neighbors in the North.

Italy is a Roman Catholic Country with an American Pontiff.

Americans like Italy and vice-versa.

Italy manufactures good products!

Good Job CDR Salamander for Eyes on Italy!

I’ve been to Greece, the Greek Islands, Vienna, Spain, Gibraltar and Portugal.

Italy has superb seamanship!

Let Italy decide what they want to make for the NATO Alliance. Regards, Nurse Jane

Dale Flowers's avatar

Belgium and Luxembourg sitting at around 1.25%...what? They got overrun and occupied in a few days in WWI and WWII and pretty much sat those wars out waiting for rescue. They have been grifting since April 1949. Time to part ways with the grifters or send in Vito to break bones.

Pete's avatar

Belgians did put up a fight in WWI. May have saved Paris.

brent_maz's avatar

And not just a Navy. They need a Coast Guard as well at the very least to attempt the flow of migrants from North Africa.

CP's avatar

Sì! Ma Bruxelles…

Andy's avatar

They seem to have a slightly different division of work as the OPVs and larger are in the actual navy for the most part. Their Coast Guard starts at about our FRC sized ship, a little bigger.

Sebastian Bruns's avatar

It should be mentioned that Italy has Navy Law which specifies that (and what) ships need to be paid for, built and maintained to grow a navy. Remarkable, but - a long-term legalistic way of things.

Mattis2024's avatar

I should mention US has a constitutional requirement to Maintain a Navy. And only raise an Army. Yet since Goldwater-Nicols & then Clinton the Army has run things

Brian J. Dunn's avatar

I’ve long figured Italy (surely France would participate, too, right??) would be the core of a NATO air-naval force that made sure Russia’s Mediterranean flotilla led a short but exciting life in a war.

Andy's avatar

All one submarine with tug escort these days.

HMSLion's avatar

P-8s are good, but I’d also put money into MQ-4s. Quite possibly without the SIGINT package (which is very expensive). The radar on that beast is a formidable asset.

HMSLion's avatar

There’s something bigger…NATO can be broadly broken up into front-line states facing Russia (former Warsaw Pact, plus Finland, Sweden, and Germany), and the rear area powers (U.S./UK, especially, but Italy also). The latter should focus on providing air power and seapower to the alliance.

Mattis2024's avatar

NATO is a mutual defense pact with responsibilities beyond Europe.

When the CCP attacks the US they better be prepared to sent troops.

Captain Mongo's avatar

Served two tours in Italy, first was a national tour (CTF-63/COMNAVSURFMED) second a NATO tour with NAVSOUTH--which was the remnant of CINCMED, now under a (part time) Italian 4 star, but most of the staff were UK. Got to appreciate the Italian Navy quite a bit--very professional, but in a more laid back way than we were. Excellent ships.

My take was that the Italian politics were so chaotic that getting any kind of sustained defense commitment out of the government was a minor miracle. It is helpful to remember that there are really three Italys: Rome/Florence. The industrial North, and the South. Of course Sicily is an exception almost everything. Those three have radically different ideas about where resources are to be allocated and who gets to decide that allocation. Overlay that with a score or more of political parties and you can appreciate the problem.

There is also that most Italians have primary allegiance to theit family, second to their village or neighborhood and only lastly to the nation. This makes getting a unified anything agreed upon problematical.

Mattis2024's avatar

Even with all that they have been able to do some remarkable things with their MIC.