They don’t want us to be heroes. We look wrong and have thoughts the media industry does not like. It was said the only way they could portray the modern military like that was if we were fighting an extra-terrestrial threat.
The oikophobia of the cultural class is just insulting.
Like Vietnam some came home with problems, but the majority came home, got married, got divorced, got jobs and raised families and settled back in but, they were different in good and bad ways from their civilian counter parts.
I know 4 personally, all Marines, only one came home with problems, but he was an 0311 and saw some bad combat. But he is stable now.
We all came home, and restarted life. But we never were the same after.
Bill Mauldin (of "Willie and Joe" fame) wrote a book , "Back Home", about his and other veterans return to the US and their readjustments. Good read, plenty of cartoons for those of us who have trouble with our words. It seems veterans back then were also crazed and on the verge of committing multiple axe murders. "Plus ca change, plus c'est la meme chose".
My Dad, several of my uncles and their friends came home had us kids and never turned into axe murderers, Even those who saw hard combat, one of our policemen was a 101st Airborne veteran, Purple heart medals the whole shebang and on the job never shot anyone. The majority of the millions who served never saw combat, they were logistics, supply clerks say 9 out of ten.
So where outside of cartoons did you come up with this?
I think his point was that even after WWII, there were people who pushed the idea that this was what veterans are like -- and I suspect that "Back Home" (and other books by Bill Mauldin, as I discovered by looking up the first) was mocking the idea that WWII vets were crazed and on the verge of multiple axe murderers.
CDR Sal, "They" did / are / will continue to "shape / influence / propagandize" public perception using every tool at their disposal. And it works. Better on some than others, but when viewed as a population, it works very well. The dawn of the social media age took things up a couple of levels. The use of AI (tailored to the desires of the one paying the bills) will level up the ability of MISO types to "influence" public opinion even more effectively. To quote someone much smarter than me "if you get your news from CBS / PBS / NPR, you are not being informed. You are being trained." He said that ten years ago, IIRC.
One is left to wonder whether the PBS decision was driven by a recognition that they need to broaden their audience now that CPB-distributed funding from Uncle Sugar is no longer forthcoming.
at least a year late. The sort of person who watched the content and came away with a slightly better opinion of PBS might have been useful to keep the funds flowing earlier, but is not going to be writing 5 figure checks to replace Uncle Sugga now.
Airing it was an easy acquiescence because they've been getting crapped-on by everyone from the center rightwards, to include the executive branch. Nevermind it was produced 17-yrs ago, and only a few had heard of it prior.
I've been looking for a decent refresh of World at War for 25 years. The last I saw the best restored version out there cut off 10-15% top and bottom to expand it to 16x9.
Currently I watch Time ghost Army history on youtube, They have covered the entire WW1, WW2 with a segment devoted to the 24 hours of Pearl Harbor and one for D-Day, they are now in the Korean war and covering the cold war.
I watched the Last 600M with my Wife yesterday. I was in that area with the Army during much of the period the film takes place in. This documentary did a great job explaining from a warfighters view what it was like.
My Wife does not understand when I get upset that PBS very rarely puts out any product that doesn't have an almost anti-American slant. Whatever limited programming always finds something on the edges that detracts from whatever valor or sacrifice has been achieved. Are we always right no, but the amount of blood spilled needs to be respected. Esprit de Corps I was taught is pride in one's military legion and we need more of that not less. Hopefully they learn a lesson with this film. Very proud of our Marines and all veterans. Thanks Commander Sal for all you do.
Kind of like how I don’t want to watch the latest Ken Burns series on The Revolutionary War. Just know it’s going to be 1619 Project-centered stuff on how it wasn’t really a revolution and we all suck and blah blah…
"CEO Paula Kerger decided to broadcast it upon reexamination. Pack credited her courage in reversing the company’s past decisions."
I'd be interested in talking about her courage. Same or different from the Marines in Iraq? Was she following orders? Whose? Is there a strategic plan she's following? Have facts on the ground required her to rethink the old tactics? What's the desired outcome? In whose face is she being courageous? I don't know, but I have suspicions about all of those.
In any case, I think we're talking about a thing different, even though I agree that standing up the left-mob requires courage, too.
On the 11th, I found "The Battle of Britain" one of the Frank Capra's "Why We Fight" WWII documentaries on You Tube. Serious, factual and riveting...should be required viewing in high school's today...no chance, paddles, wave him off!!!
"Let’s take Victory at Sea. It came out in 1952, seven years after the end of WWII. The documentary was a long series about a very broad topic with about 13 hours’ run time."
An excellent series with an excellent sound track based on Richard Rodgers' vision (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victory_at_Sea#Music). If you like sweeping thematic orchestrations, you will like the music on its own. That said, the video and music together have a synergy that is second to none.
They don’t want us to be heroes. We look wrong and have thoughts the media industry does not like. It was said the only way they could portray the modern military like that was if we were fighting an extra-terrestrial threat.
The oikophobia of the cultural class is just insulting.
Yes, and we know who the people who look right to them actually are.
The same people spitting on ICE are the same people who spit on those returning from Vietnam.
The Boomer protesters were the same Vietnam Protestors of that and this era.
There it is.
Just like the return from Vietnam, they want the vet message to be disillusionment, homelessness, drugs and PTSD
Like Vietnam some came home with problems, but the majority came home, got married, got divorced, got jobs and raised families and settled back in but, they were different in good and bad ways from their civilian counter parts.
I know 4 personally, all Marines, only one came home with problems, but he was an 0311 and saw some bad combat. But he is stable now.
We all came home, and restarted life. But we never were the same after.
all gave some
some gave all
Spokes inside a wheel, without the multitude of spokes the wheel does not work.
Bill Mauldin (of "Willie and Joe" fame) wrote a book , "Back Home", about his and other veterans return to the US and their readjustments. Good read, plenty of cartoons for those of us who have trouble with our words. It seems veterans back then were also crazed and on the verge of committing multiple axe murders. "Plus ca change, plus c'est la meme chose".
My Dad, several of my uncles and their friends came home had us kids and never turned into axe murderers, Even those who saw hard combat, one of our policemen was a 101st Airborne veteran, Purple heart medals the whole shebang and on the job never shot anyone. The majority of the millions who served never saw combat, they were logistics, supply clerks say 9 out of ten.
So where outside of cartoons did you come up with this?
I think his point was that even after WWII, there were people who pushed the idea that this was what veterans are like -- and I suspect that "Back Home" (and other books by Bill Mauldin, as I discovered by looking up the first) was mocking the idea that WWII vets were crazed and on the verge of multiple axe murderers.
CDR Sal, "They" did / are / will continue to "shape / influence / propagandize" public perception using every tool at their disposal. And it works. Better on some than others, but when viewed as a population, it works very well. The dawn of the social media age took things up a couple of levels. The use of AI (tailored to the desires of the one paying the bills) will level up the ability of MISO types to "influence" public opinion even more effectively. To quote someone much smarter than me "if you get your news from CBS / PBS / NPR, you are not being informed. You are being trained." He said that ten years ago, IIRC.
I watched The Last 600 metres a couple of years ago. I heard about it during an interview of Michael Peck. Thanks for the pointer to Victory at Sea. I found it on Prime Video, https://www.primevideo.com/region/na/detail/0QL6O3M4CRPP0WLPJYYAMCRB1P/ref=atv_dp_share_cu_r
It's on You Tube was well.
One is left to wonder whether the PBS decision was driven by a recognition that they need to broaden their audience now that CPB-distributed funding from Uncle Sugar is no longer forthcoming.
at least a year late. The sort of person who watched the content and came away with a slightly better opinion of PBS might have been useful to keep the funds flowing earlier, but is not going to be writing 5 figure checks to replace Uncle Sugga now.
Their hubris prevented that. They, like all the others feeding at the trough, thought they were untouchable.
It would be interesting to know what the rationale was for running it now is.
There's much to be cynical about.
Airing it was an easy acquiescence because they've been getting crapped-on by everyone from the center rightwards, to include the executive branch. Nevermind it was produced 17-yrs ago, and only a few had heard of it prior.
There are over 24 years of that wars veterans out here now, that is a too large audience to ignore.
Brilliant example. Adding to my watch list.
I'll watch it tonight.
"Victory at Sea" was always a favorite of mine, along with "The World at War," narrated by Laurence Olivier.
PR, but to my liking
I've been looking for a decent refresh of World at War for 25 years. The last I saw the best restored version out there cut off 10-15% top and bottom to expand it to 16x9.
Go to youtube and seek Time Ghost Army.
Thanks!
Currently I watch Time ghost Army history on youtube, They have covered the entire WW1, WW2 with a segment devoted to the 24 hours of Pearl Harbor and one for D-Day, they are now in the Korean war and covering the cold war.
The sound track was pretty decent, too.
I watched the Last 600M with my Wife yesterday. I was in that area with the Army during much of the period the film takes place in. This documentary did a great job explaining from a warfighters view what it was like.
My Wife does not understand when I get upset that PBS very rarely puts out any product that doesn't have an almost anti-American slant. Whatever limited programming always finds something on the edges that detracts from whatever valor or sacrifice has been achieved. Are we always right no, but the amount of blood spilled needs to be respected. Esprit de Corps I was taught is pride in one's military legion and we need more of that not less. Hopefully they learn a lesson with this film. Very proud of our Marines and all veterans. Thanks Commander Sal for all you do.
"...almost..." ? You're being over-generous
Kind of like how I don’t want to watch the latest Ken Burns series on The Revolutionary War. Just know it’s going to be 1619 Project-centered stuff on how it wasn’t really a revolution and we all suck and blah blah…
I am quite ready to start with some high level impalements, or crucifixions, Col. Kratman style would be the best, I think.
stakes are more ecologically sound. conserves wood. short stakes even better
iirc in the book series they kept metal crosses around so they could reuse them...
u can look heroic on a cross. that Jewish lad did. its hard to look heroic squatting on a stake with various fluids dripping down quivering legs
Equally unpleasant, perhaps more so
Vlad certainly did good work with them.
or Col Kurtz
Thanks for further validation of the decision to defend CPB/PBS
“defend” or “defund”?
Defund. Fat fingers and autocorrect strike again.
I'd have to see it to judge it.
There's no way of telling otherwise.
"CEO Paula Kerger decided to broadcast it upon reexamination. Pack credited her courage in reversing the company’s past decisions."
I'd be interested in talking about her courage. Same or different from the Marines in Iraq? Was she following orders? Whose? Is there a strategic plan she's following? Have facts on the ground required her to rethink the old tactics? What's the desired outcome? In whose face is she being courageous? I don't know, but I have suspicions about all of those.
In any case, I think we're talking about a thing different, even though I agree that standing up the left-mob requires courage, too.
Sal, thanks for the steer.
On the 11th, I found "The Battle of Britain" one of the Frank Capra's "Why We Fight" WWII documentaries on You Tube. Serious, factual and riveting...should be required viewing in high school's today...no chance, paddles, wave him off!!!
"Let’s take Victory at Sea. It came out in 1952, seven years after the end of WWII. The documentary was a long series about a very broad topic with about 13 hours’ run time."
An excellent series with an excellent sound track based on Richard Rodgers' vision (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victory_at_Sea#Music). If you like sweeping thematic orchestrations, you will like the music on its own. That said, the video and music together have a synergy that is second to none.
"And now......"