Pete, the frontline is probably about 700-800 miles. The territorial gains (as mentioned by our host.) aren't all that great by the standards of Pavel Rybalko or modern manuever warfare. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pavel_Rybalko
But not bad compared to the Battle of Amiens where an 8 mile advance was celebrated.
The press releases in this case are weeks, even months, behind the reality....the Ukrainian's have been holding back on any releases of drone footage...but some has sneaked out and been geolocated....and the Russian's have been releasing drone footage...that when geolocated revealed that the fighting was actually miles behind their own claimed frontline....
The reality is that fighting is now happening, and has been for over a week, at the Zerebets River....even Russian bloggers/mappers with contacts on their side are now talking about this...and the Ukrainians are still moving forward. Thats 14km behind the furthest Russian front line position (not Gray Zone) as currently mapped on DeepState. DeepState has been holding OPSEC and is only channging their map as the Ukrainian Command announces it....not when others are....
An 8 mile advance over 4 days (8-12 Aug., 1918 in Wikipedia) was pretty decent on the Western Front. Compares favorably to 340 sq. kilometers over 4 months, I'd say.
European politics provides a very useful window into future U.S. politics should the progressives take control. Right leaning political parties continue to win elections but deliberately created "firewalls" and media control (including outright censorship of "wrong think") have so far prevented any meaningful change in France or Germany. There is a strong undercurrent of "war is coming". Unclear if this is media generated to prop up the current ruling elite or actual concern. "And" is always an option. As is "follow the money". It will be hilarious if we end up with van Der Leyn begging Tr...the U.S. to save them.
The far right, not 'Right leaning' as they actual 'Right' been part of Governments for generations, have increased their polling numbers over the years...(although they have fluctuated down, particularly come election time) no surprise there as the mainstream parties refuse to do what the electorate keep telling them...particularly on immigration...
But...even then neither Party has the numbers or backing to make headway in the world of proportional represenation. In France or Germany, RN or AfD can poll well...but as long as they are not over 50% they will not see power...because none of the other Parties will work with them. Their vote also tends to be concentrated in certain regions and thinner elsewhere, so their impact on local politics...which matters in Federal Germany or France with devolved powers, gets lessened...
There are 3 potential outcomes...
- Mainstream parties will, inexplicably and insanely, continue to ignore the electorate...and their power and control will wither....until...a Far Right Party gets to get put a minority administration in....this will not work well due to their inability to pass any laws...or....
- They grasp the bull by the horns like the Danish did....massively tighten up on immigration/asylum....and effectively remove the Far Rights main reason for being....or....
- The Far Right see sense....get rid of the grifters, chancers and (clearly) Russian sponsored leaders and members whose presence turns many away, develop actual policy platforms that are coherent, priced up and spells out what their legislative plans are in detail....then they are actually in with a shot of getting in power....none have been bright enough to do that yet....
I was wondering about the tank picture. It appears (to my imperfect tank ID skills) to be some variant on a T72. I was worried it was a Leopard 1 or 2 but the wheels are wrong. I assume it is a staged photo as sitting out in the open like that would make it a drone magnet.
Well, Riding gets you there faster and with a tank there's nowhere inside for the infantry (exception being the Israeli Merkava.) It's a long standing tradition with Russians to do so.
With IFVs/APCs the infantry does tend to ride on top as it's safer if you hit a mine. And, especially for the Soviet models, it's a lot quicker to unass. And that that says something since, as you note, they would be a drone magnet. (Though, to be fair, any vehicle seems to be a drone magnet and it seems likely the first attempts would be to disable the vehicle itself rather than worry about the infantry.)
German infantry in WWII did ride on the tanks at times as well. You would also see infantry on foot clustered behind an advancing tank using if for cover. That seemed to be a pretty universal tactic.
In WWII, I think the issue was more mobility than mine avoidance but I could be mistaken. Certainly the carriers for infantry were quite different, lightly armored and open topped, so nowhere to sit there.
If you ever watch 1917 through to its conclusion - two hours of grueling and well-done World War I cinema, the commander they\he finally delivers the message to says: "I hoped today might be a good day. Hope is a dangerous thing. That’s it for now, then next week, Command will send a different message. Attack at dawn. There is only one way this war ends. Last man standing."
They have their places. Both sides use IFVs/APCs to deliver assault troops over open ground to where they dismount to clear the trenches. These assaults are typically accompanied by tanks for fire support.
But it's not the North German Plain or Fulda Gap scenario we all thought WWIII would be. The battles tend to be for more localized objectives than sweeping fights. But all battles really consist of a series of local fights. What happens when one is won is what turns them into mobile mechanized battles, or simply taking a hill or strongpoint before regrouping for the next battle.
"We should not get too excited. 29 square miles (75 square kilometers) is only a bit larger than Manhattan and a little smaller than Walt Disney World. If we scaled that up proportionally for the USA, that would be about 490 square miles, or the city of Los Angeles. Not nothing, but not a lot."
It is horrifying to check out a map over on ISW/ CRITICAL THREATS⏰ and see how far Russian forces have advanced west from Bakhmut in two years. This whole terrible waste of men and cities is absolutely insane and heartbreaking. 🗺️📍💥🩸⚰️
"Russia’s leadership had hoped to encircle Ukraine’s formidable fortress belt in western Donbas, but the northern salient has been reduced, with Russian warbloggers claiming it will extend the battle for Donbas by a year. Credible independent sources say the Ukrainian territorial gain is even greater." 🇺🇦✅ ~exactly🗺️
The funniest thing is....the Kremlin delusion, with Putin looking like a fool....
Putin himself, a few weeks ago, announced the capture of the city of Sviatohirsk, which was the objective of this northern pincer....the next day Biletskyi, the Commander of the 3rd Corps of the Ukrainian Army posted a brand new video of him walking around Sviatohirsk in total peace....no gunfire whatsoever...the Ukrainian offensive had been underway to the east for weeks at the time....
The Russian High Command, as of yesterday, is now ridiculously claiming that Russian soldiers are in the outskirts of Sviatohirsk...which is widely derided by Russian bloggers and mappers as the actual fighting is 25km away with the Russian's being pushed further back....
Its got a 'Kupyansk+' feeling about it....false reports heading upwards, each time getting more and more embellished, all the way to Putin who then reads them out on national TV and looks like an absolute chump....
What Sal has missed is that the Ukrainian offensive has effectively retaken defensible high ground down to the Zerebets River (and there are even Russian reports of fighting in Terny and Yampolivka ACROSS the river) if they finish this off they will have re-established an easily defensible position that took the Russian's 18 months of tremendous losses to move through...and blocked any attempt to take the Sloviansk/Kramatorsk agglomeration by pincer for the foreseeable (Russian attempts further north are being held back and are, regardless, constrained by the Oskil River and City of Kupiansk, where they suffered a big defeat over the last 6 months.
The Russian Summer Offensive of 2026 has been a complete, and total failure....
So was Germany fighting on French soil in WW1, but we see how that ended. There comes a point where all countries break. The question is does it go like the Russian Revolution in 1917, the French republican revolt in the 1870 Frano-Germany war, or the Kaiser's abdication in 1918. I have lost hope on TR settling the Russo-Japanese War. At least in that one, the Japanese knew they reached a culmination point and pulled out their escape plan and the Russians with the beginnings of civil unrest wisely accepted the terms.
Although off the point of the article, I would suggest that Vivaldi made a nice third career for himself being celebrated and feted all across Europe for artistic inspiration that originated in the young orphaned girls being groomed as household servants for the wealthy families in Italy at the time.
The "Four Seasons" is most well known because of its melodies, but the real fireworks took place in the Opus 3 "L'estro Armonico". Listen to the concertos for four violins, its hard not to hear a group of young orphan girls playing with and against each other in the dormitory of the orphanage, were it not for them, I doubt their would be any historical record of an Antonio Vivaldi.
Leaving politics aside for a moment, if one looks to a semi neutral newspaper NZZ, which is a Swiss entity, they publish a daily “real time” map of the battle space in Eastern Ukraine aka the Donbas. If one looks at the map, the Ukrainian “offensive” is not really working as it is nearly non existent. Then notice a familiar sight, fingers of Russian Federation advances making pincer like moments across the front, more like a 1000 miles long. They have been developing a series of cauldrons which are close to encircling the stranded and logistics challenged Ukrainian forces. When the cauldrons close the units will be trapped. We have seen this movie before in much of the same territory in 1943-1944. Western Europe has chosen the time and place of the battle. Their answer currently is to allow Ukrainian leadership the latitude using western arms to blow up diesel refining capacity in Russia. It’s a big country by the way, some thing like 240 million population and 8-10 times zones from east to west. This winter will be interesting for Western Europe, fat dumb and stupid is no way to go through life, neither is living in the cold and dark. Whether anyone likes Putin or Trump or pick your politician, the facts on the ground are so that slow overwhelming force and the war footing economy at a war armaments level, will out pace the economies which cannot match it. We won WWII because the USA out produced the world. The Russians are producing 12,00 rounds of 155mm shells a week. They are producing 300 T-90 tanks a year. The newer versions have significant anti drone capabilities. The maneuver warfare discussed is not Ukrainian driven, rather Russian Federation forces maneuvering across a wide battle space. The defenders stuck in set piece defensive posture. USMC Infantry Officers Course teaches when out numbered by superior forces to be mobile, defend in depth, with strong point portions that are flexible and ever changing and counter attacks at stretched logistics and forces positions of vulnerability. That is not happening at the moment. One might ask if it is going so well for the Ukrainian forces, why is retired 3 star general Kieth Kellog suggesting that conscription of Ukrainian women aged 18 to 25 is a good idea? Asking for a friend. The same General says Russian forces will be defeated and kicked out the Donbas. Rumors have it that several drapes have gone missing in the Us Embassy in Kiev, and portions found in General Kellogg’s hotel room, waiting for confirmation that he has indeed been smoking the drapes. One would also ask, if the Russians are so lousy at war fighting in Ukraine why the western Politicians so frightened of a Russian blitz attack across the Fulda Gap? Again just asking for a friend. Since one or the other is right or wrong.
I don't care who wins or who loses as long as the USA stays out of it. Both are corrupt socialist Kleptocracy's Both aren't worth one dime or one good spit of tobacco juice.
I don't care who started it as long as both end it in a peace deal or until both sides mutually destroy each other.
Don't come at me Kogut lovers and Russki lovers I said my piece and I stand on it.
Ukrainian self determination. That’s very rich. Apparently French and German self determination aren’t as important, if they impair Ukrainian Self Determination.
American self determination also isn’t particularly interested in foreign adventures.
What if there was an Empire that nobody wanted, couldn’t afford and wouldn’t fight for…because it only benefited a few? In any real test especially from within this Empire would collapse. The Germans to study aren’t the ones the Ukrainian Nazis study. Study the Hapsburg’s at the end.
CDR,
Is this the same Mick Ryan associated with the CSIS a “bipartisan” DC think tank?
If so call me skeptical about any Ukrainian victories on the battlefield.
I haven’t forgotten the “Ghost of Kiev.”
No one is perfect. I sure am not.
True dat. Past track records can provide betting odds for future accuracy projections, however...
You leave Sam H. out of this!
Pete, the frontline is probably about 700-800 miles. The territorial gains (as mentioned by our host.) aren't all that great by the standards of Pavel Rybalko or modern manuever warfare. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pavel_Rybalko
But not bad compared to the Battle of Amiens where an 8 mile advance was celebrated.
There are advances and there are advances.
The Germans were advancing on Paris in the Spring of ‘18 until they weren’t.
My point is that I don’t believe the press releases.
A 75 mile bump on 700+ mile front? Not even a "bulge."
The press releases in this case are weeks, even months, behind the reality....the Ukrainian's have been holding back on any releases of drone footage...but some has sneaked out and been geolocated....and the Russian's have been releasing drone footage...that when geolocated revealed that the fighting was actually miles behind their own claimed frontline....
The reality is that fighting is now happening, and has been for over a week, at the Zerebets River....even Russian bloggers/mappers with contacts on their side are now talking about this...and the Ukrainians are still moving forward. Thats 14km behind the furthest Russian front line position (not Gray Zone) as currently mapped on DeepState. DeepState has been holding OPSEC and is only channging their map as the Ukrainian Command announces it....not when others are....
No way to know what reality is.
Even leaks may not really be leaks.
An 8 mile advance over 4 days (8-12 Aug., 1918 in Wikipedia) was pretty decent on the Western Front. Compares favorably to 340 sq. kilometers over 4 months, I'd say.
Before mechanized infantry.
"I haven’t forgotten the “Ghost of Kiev"
Ah yes, that incident when the Ukrainians (checks notes) exaggerated a pilot's aerial victories.
Such a heinous and deceitful thing has never been done by any other nation at war, ever.
That’s precisely my point.
You can’t believe the press releases.
I'd buy that if it didn't seem like you have an isolated demand for rigor when it comes to anything involving the Ukrainians not losing.
Actually I do because I don’t believe Ukraine is of any concern to us.
I believe this war is the result of pushing NATO to the East and trying to make the Black Sea into a NATO lake.
I believe that we pushed Russia into the arms of China and now face the entire Asian landmass.
Need I go on?
"In wartime, truth is so precious that she should always be attended by a bodyguard of lies."
— Winston Churchill
Heinous and deceitful is not even necessary when rumors and exaggerations are as widespread as they are during wartime.
European politics provides a very useful window into future U.S. politics should the progressives take control. Right leaning political parties continue to win elections but deliberately created "firewalls" and media control (including outright censorship of "wrong think") have so far prevented any meaningful change in France or Germany. There is a strong undercurrent of "war is coming". Unclear if this is media generated to prop up the current ruling elite or actual concern. "And" is always an option. As is "follow the money". It will be hilarious if we end up with van Der Leyn begging Tr...the U.S. to save them.
You're reaching a bit there....
The far right, not 'Right leaning' as they actual 'Right' been part of Governments for generations, have increased their polling numbers over the years...(although they have fluctuated down, particularly come election time) no surprise there as the mainstream parties refuse to do what the electorate keep telling them...particularly on immigration...
But...even then neither Party has the numbers or backing to make headway in the world of proportional represenation. In France or Germany, RN or AfD can poll well...but as long as they are not over 50% they will not see power...because none of the other Parties will work with them. Their vote also tends to be concentrated in certain regions and thinner elsewhere, so their impact on local politics...which matters in Federal Germany or France with devolved powers, gets lessened...
There are 3 potential outcomes...
- Mainstream parties will, inexplicably and insanely, continue to ignore the electorate...and their power and control will wither....until...a Far Right Party gets to get put a minority administration in....this will not work well due to their inability to pass any laws...or....
- They grasp the bull by the horns like the Danish did....massively tighten up on immigration/asylum....and effectively remove the Far Rights main reason for being....or....
- The Far Right see sense....get rid of the grifters, chancers and (clearly) Russian sponsored leaders and members whose presence turns many away, develop actual policy platforms that are coherent, priced up and spells out what their legislative plans are in detail....then they are actually in with a shot of getting in power....none have been bright enough to do that yet....
So we agree!
I was wondering about the tank picture. It appears (to my imperfect tank ID skills) to be some variant on a T72. I was worried it was a Leopard 1 or 2 but the wheels are wrong. I assume it is a staged photo as sitting out in the open like that would make it a drone magnet.
It's a T64. Good call on the road wheels. Dead giveaway.
Well, Riding gets you there faster and with a tank there's nowhere inside for the infantry (exception being the Israeli Merkava.) It's a long standing tradition with Russians to do so.
With IFVs/APCs the infantry does tend to ride on top as it's safer if you hit a mine. And, especially for the Soviet models, it's a lot quicker to unass. And that that says something since, as you note, they would be a drone magnet. (Though, to be fair, any vehicle seems to be a drone magnet and it seems likely the first attempts would be to disable the vehicle itself rather than worry about the infantry.)
It looks like some of the German pictures also show the infantry on top probably for the reasons you state
German infantry in WWII did ride on the tanks at times as well. You would also see infantry on foot clustered behind an advancing tank using if for cover. That seemed to be a pretty universal tactic.
In WWII, I think the issue was more mobility than mine avoidance but I could be mistaken. Certainly the carriers for infantry were quite different, lightly armored and open topped, so nowhere to sit there.
Definitely mobility. Soviets didn't have enough trucks even with massive aid from US and nobody's trucks could handle the poor going in the East
If you ever watch 1917 through to its conclusion - two hours of grueling and well-done World War I cinema, the commander they\he finally delivers the message to says: "I hoped today might be a good day. Hope is a dangerous thing. That’s it for now, then next week, Command will send a different message. Attack at dawn. There is only one way this war ends. Last man standing."
Interesting, isn't it?
Thanks CDR Sal for the unbiased update.
The musical reference is very fitting for this tragedy of epic proportions.
I'll always prefer Vivaldi over Tchaikovsky any day.
If the tank is losing it's efficacy then does it mean that the use of armored fighting vehicles and mechanized infantry is also in decline?
They have their places. Both sides use IFVs/APCs to deliver assault troops over open ground to where they dismount to clear the trenches. These assaults are typically accompanied by tanks for fire support.
But it's not the North German Plain or Fulda Gap scenario we all thought WWIII would be. The battles tend to be for more localized objectives than sweeping fights. But all battles really consist of a series of local fights. What happens when one is won is what turns them into mobile mechanized battles, or simply taking a hill or strongpoint before regrouping for the next battle.
⛪🤕🇷🇺🩻❄️🇺🇦🩼💀🏚️😣 Lord, have mercy.....
"We should not get too excited. 29 square miles (75 square kilometers) is only a bit larger than Manhattan and a little smaller than Walt Disney World. If we scaled that up proportionally for the USA, that would be about 490 square miles, or the city of Los Angeles. Not nothing, but not a lot."
It is horrifying to check out a map over on ISW/ CRITICAL THREATS⏰ and see how far Russian forces have advanced west from Bakhmut in two years. This whole terrible waste of men and cities is absolutely insane and heartbreaking. 🗺️📍💥🩸⚰️
Man is the cruelest animal.
Nietzsche
The fortress belt ~ 🍌 the banana on the charts.
"Russia’s leadership had hoped to encircle Ukraine’s formidable fortress belt in western Donbas, but the northern salient has been reduced, with Russian warbloggers claiming it will extend the battle for Donbas by a year. Credible independent sources say the Ukrainian territorial gain is even greater." 🇺🇦✅ ~exactly🗺️
Lyman ~ Slovyansk (9/21) 🇷🇺🗺️🇺🇦 ~north end of the Fortress Belt:
https://www.criticalthreats.org/analysis/russian-offensive-campaign-assessment-september-21-2026
Russia building underground assembly plants for Geran type drones (-4 & -5 jet powered have been a real problem 🏁📡📲 for Kiev!)
The funniest thing is....the Kremlin delusion, with Putin looking like a fool....
Putin himself, a few weeks ago, announced the capture of the city of Sviatohirsk, which was the objective of this northern pincer....the next day Biletskyi, the Commander of the 3rd Corps of the Ukrainian Army posted a brand new video of him walking around Sviatohirsk in total peace....no gunfire whatsoever...the Ukrainian offensive had been underway to the east for weeks at the time....
The Russian High Command, as of yesterday, is now ridiculously claiming that Russian soldiers are in the outskirts of Sviatohirsk...which is widely derided by Russian bloggers and mappers as the actual fighting is 25km away with the Russian's being pushed further back....
Its got a 'Kupyansk+' feeling about it....false reports heading upwards, each time getting more and more embellished, all the way to Putin who then reads them out on national TV and looks like an absolute chump....
What Sal has missed is that the Ukrainian offensive has effectively retaken defensible high ground down to the Zerebets River (and there are even Russian reports of fighting in Terny and Yampolivka ACROSS the river) if they finish this off they will have re-established an easily defensible position that took the Russian's 18 months of tremendous losses to move through...and blocked any attempt to take the Sloviansk/Kramatorsk agglomeration by pincer for the foreseeable (Russian attempts further north are being held back and are, regardless, constrained by the Oskil River and City of Kupiansk, where they suffered a big defeat over the last 6 months.
The Russian Summer Offensive of 2026 has been a complete, and total failure....
And yet the fighting is still on Ukrainian, not Russian, territory.
So was Germany fighting on French soil in WW1, but we see how that ended. There comes a point where all countries break. The question is does it go like the Russian Revolution in 1917, the French republican revolt in the 1870 Frano-Germany war, or the Kaiser's abdication in 1918. I have lost hope on TR settling the Russo-Japanese War. At least in that one, the Japanese knew they reached a culmination point and pulled out their escape plan and the Russians with the beginnings of civil unrest wisely accepted the terms.
Although off the point of the article, I would suggest that Vivaldi made a nice third career for himself being celebrated and feted all across Europe for artistic inspiration that originated in the young orphaned girls being groomed as household servants for the wealthy families in Italy at the time.
The "Four Seasons" is most well known because of its melodies, but the real fireworks took place in the Opus 3 "L'estro Armonico". Listen to the concertos for four violins, its hard not to hear a group of young orphan girls playing with and against each other in the dormitory of the orphanage, were it not for them, I doubt their would be any historical record of an Antonio Vivaldi.
Leaving politics aside for a moment, if one looks to a semi neutral newspaper NZZ, which is a Swiss entity, they publish a daily “real time” map of the battle space in Eastern Ukraine aka the Donbas. If one looks at the map, the Ukrainian “offensive” is not really working as it is nearly non existent. Then notice a familiar sight, fingers of Russian Federation advances making pincer like moments across the front, more like a 1000 miles long. They have been developing a series of cauldrons which are close to encircling the stranded and logistics challenged Ukrainian forces. When the cauldrons close the units will be trapped. We have seen this movie before in much of the same territory in 1943-1944. Western Europe has chosen the time and place of the battle. Their answer currently is to allow Ukrainian leadership the latitude using western arms to blow up diesel refining capacity in Russia. It’s a big country by the way, some thing like 240 million population and 8-10 times zones from east to west. This winter will be interesting for Western Europe, fat dumb and stupid is no way to go through life, neither is living in the cold and dark. Whether anyone likes Putin or Trump or pick your politician, the facts on the ground are so that slow overwhelming force and the war footing economy at a war armaments level, will out pace the economies which cannot match it. We won WWII because the USA out produced the world. The Russians are producing 12,00 rounds of 155mm shells a week. They are producing 300 T-90 tanks a year. The newer versions have significant anti drone capabilities. The maneuver warfare discussed is not Ukrainian driven, rather Russian Federation forces maneuvering across a wide battle space. The defenders stuck in set piece defensive posture. USMC Infantry Officers Course teaches when out numbered by superior forces to be mobile, defend in depth, with strong point portions that are flexible and ever changing and counter attacks at stretched logistics and forces positions of vulnerability. That is not happening at the moment. One might ask if it is going so well for the Ukrainian forces, why is retired 3 star general Kieth Kellog suggesting that conscription of Ukrainian women aged 18 to 25 is a good idea? Asking for a friend. The same General says Russian forces will be defeated and kicked out the Donbas. Rumors have it that several drapes have gone missing in the Us Embassy in Kiev, and portions found in General Kellogg’s hotel room, waiting for confirmation that he has indeed been smoking the drapes. One would also ask, if the Russians are so lousy at war fighting in Ukraine why the western Politicians so frightened of a Russian blitz attack across the Fulda Gap? Again just asking for a friend. Since one or the other is right or wrong.
"why the western Politicians so frightened of a Russian blitz attack across the Fulda Gap?"
1) Nostalgia.
2) Politicians always need a scapegoat.
3) Ignorance
4) Etc.
I don't care who wins or who loses as long as the USA stays out of it. Both are corrupt socialist Kleptocracy's Both aren't worth one dime or one good spit of tobacco juice.
I don't care who started it as long as both end it in a peace deal or until both sides mutually destroy each other.
Don't come at me Kogut lovers and Russki lovers I said my piece and I stand on it.
Russia is what, at a million dead? They're only getting started. Madness on all sides but encouraging Z man is the worst.
Ukrainian self determination. That’s very rich. Apparently French and German self determination aren’t as important, if they impair Ukrainian Self Determination.
American self determination also isn’t particularly interested in foreign adventures.
What if there was an Empire that nobody wanted, couldn’t afford and wouldn’t fight for…because it only benefited a few? In any real test especially from within this Empire would collapse. The Germans to study aren’t the ones the Ukrainian Nazis study. Study the Hapsburg’s at the end.