19 Comments

IIRC the Lib crew did not survive the war.

"Sometimes you eat the bear, sometimes, the bear eats you"

Expand full comment

Being on 3 Frigates, 1 Destroyer and 1 Aegis Cruiser, ASW was a thing. Got to do the writing down of bearings and ranges of the contact on a plexiglass status board for the DRT/NC2 plotter, the DRT South Plotter, DRT North Plotter, ASAC-er (MAD, ETI, Julie and Jezebel buoys...Steuf's, Neptunes and Sea Kings...where else could a 20 year old have such fun?), CICO. ASW, in my view, was the biggest challenge for us. Much of it was voodoo in the old days. Bet those guys on G-George never had to buy another beer.

Expand full comment

After they returned, "About three hours later I saw him carrying plates of fish and chips to the other members of his crew still in their beds.”

Says a bit about the man, and his leadership. Well done, sir.

Expand full comment

British "Ultra" intelligence was so successful at locating boat future positions, attacks had to be artificially randomized, data left unshared with some naive and leaky allies, and even reducing numbers of attacks so as not raising suspicion that codes were completely cracked risking encryption changes. The wars at sea then were won with what is now called cyber.

Expand full comment

G George was a flying ENGLAND!

Expand full comment

Even in mid-44 with U-boats mostly driven to impotence, running an attack with a glass nose B-24 took some big brass ones. (The boats had up-armed and were staying on the surface to fight it out.)

The other big brass ones? Flying an ASV Swordfish over the North Sea and the Channel in 1944-1945. That's just crazy.

Expand full comment

Why we need MOAR P-8s!

Expand full comment

Good Fullbore. I have always thought that our side could have made the 1940-43 U Boat war end much earlier if we had devoted more resources such as Liberators to ASW. Instead we frittered them away chasing the Strategic Bombing chimera.

Expand full comment

Radar was the most effective ASW tool in WWII and this story is a good illustration of that.

Expand full comment

It has been suggested that long range naval bombers like this be used to launch strike missiles in far WestPac. Somehow the Poseidon doesn't seem like an attack aircraft to me but I am not a naval aviator~

Expand full comment

Why consider an expensive aircraft meant for transcontinental missions? Why not use an aircraft meant for infra-theather missions?

Expand full comment

As far as missiles that can be launched against the Chinese, the US is in a distinct shortage in launcher platforms both surface and air, missile inventory of many types, as opposed to China's every increasing numbers of platforms and missiles - I think

Expand full comment