186 Comments

Time to start The Ten-Thousand Centuries Of Humiliation, so the Chinese learn their lesson!

Expand full comment

Fantastic read.

Expand full comment

1) stop saying the United States won the Cold War. Last I checked the communists merely transferred their flag from Moscow to Beijing.

2) stop pretending that non-communist Russia is a threat to the west rather than an excellent potential ally for containing the CCP. It's probably to late to do that thanks to the Ukraine war, so really the US is going to have to go it alone.

3) Cleonomes and Themistocles knew that to beat the Mede abroad you first have to beat the Mede at home. The fact that US policy makers are willing to plan for shooting war with the communists but aren't willing to engage in a trade war to eliminate their stranglehold on our key strategic industries just goes to show you everything you need to know about how seriously they take the threat.

Expand full comment

Well said.

We drove Russia into the arms of China

Last I checked we never lost a single job or factory to Russia.

Now we confront the entire Eurasian landmass thereby undoing Nixon a greatest accomplishment of separating those two nations.

Expand full comment

I would also add that once the Soviet Union fell, our domestic Left became unmoored, and they have never forgiven the US fr the fall of CCCP. The Left is ascendant here as well as China.

Expand full comment

Much of the hate of Russia comes from the fact that they failed at communism.

Expand full comment

Like over 95%! Solid point.

Expand full comment

Very true. Our "main stream" media and academia were in love with the CCCP. They only started hating Russians after the gave up on the Socialist Republics.

Expand full comment

Thanks for the massive reading assignment! Well done. I'll try to have a comment after I've digested all of this.

Expand full comment

Is America even worth fighting for after seeing what this administration is doing to Donald Trump?

Everyday I see an administration less capable of dealing with the problems that affect her citizens and in fact regards those same citizens as deplorable enemies to be humiliated and beaten down.

Expand full comment

I think it is, Pete, for no greater reason than what has been orchestrated against Trump. The enemy within must be defeated before we will defeat the enemy at the gates. The Democrats have sold their souls to marxism and it's hateful manifestations. Nothing of any value will be accomplished under their regime. We need an immediate course correction.

Expand full comment

I think they have won. It’s not just Trump. What is now routine was once considered impossible. Schools encouraging children to change their gender without bothering to inform parents. Praising people who burn, loot and murder while turning the FBI loose on 1 6 trespassers or Catholics who like the Latin mass. An open border. Fraudulent elections and rigged juries. Didn’t Earn It. Need I go on? After what happened to the Marines in Kabul how can we ask any young man to risk his for this administration? Give Hunter Biden a rifle and let him fight for Taiwan.

Expand full comment

There will be no course correction. If Trump isn’t found hanging in his jail cell then millions of ballots will turn up in every inner city after midnight Election Day. These people staged a coup and have no intention of letting go for any reason.

Expand full comment

One of the things I find sadder than the pessimism I see in others is the magnitude of the poisonous pessimism I find in myself. Maybe it is time for me to quit eating the comfort food, start PT-ing again and take to heart Rev. Niemöller's famous quote.

Expand full comment

I'm in the same boat. I see myriad reasons to take the "black pill" but still think there is some chance for the cause of freedom to prevail, in some form

Expand full comment

My old boss at PacFlt, an O-5 EA-6B NFO/EWO, used to cheer me up with this: "Do you hear it, Senior Chief? Those engines in the distance? That's the air lift coming." Whether I am deluding myself or not, that has always helped me out of a blue funk since 1981.

Expand full comment

Pessimism = Reality.

Expand full comment

Dale, you are not alone. So I try to re-assure people that we will come out of this OK, that human decency will endure, that younger people will have a better life than we can imagine. That way, I leave less room in my own mind for doubt. If you lie to yourself long enough, you can believe it.

With respect to mission readiness, I always remember the mantra I received from WWII vets - keep your head down, your mouth shut, and your bowels open.

Expand full comment

Perhaps. It will indeed be fait accompli if it is not actively, even physically, resisted. I do not disagree with your points but the our late republic is worth the attempt. I don't have quit in me, these elitist swine will have to keep working for it.

Expand full comment

Who the hell cares about Donald Trump. America is worth fighting for because it is my home.

Expand full comment

You had better care about him because after they are done with him, they are coming after you - you bitter clinger. The truckers in Canada who had their back accounts frozen because they dared to protest thought that Canada was their home, too. Justin Castreau showed them otherwise.

Expand full comment

But you just said the fight is lost already. Like a dumbass.

Expand full comment

Bravo ! Spot on.

Expand full comment

One does not have to care about DJT personally to recognize that to accept what Leviathan has done to him signals the end of the Republic, and therefore cannot be accepted

Expand full comment

Wow. Really?! I don't have like Donald Trump to care what precedents the Deep State sets? My God, where were you to tell me that in May 2017 when Mendacious Moron Mueller was appointed special counsel?

Expand full comment

You are firing both barrels at someone who has never particularly disagreed with you. I think President Trump was and is great for us, and I hated/hate what was and is being done to him. My point is that even though I do support him, I care about the country independently of that, and am disgusted by what the "deep state" for lack of a better term has done to our beloved Republic in order to tear him down.

Expand full comment

Probably not fair that you took some of the fallout of my response to the Doomer account who chimed in "why bother fighting after what they did to Trump." Point is I have been angry about Deep State electoral interference since before "Deep State" was common vernacular. You think Russiagate was bad? Wait until I tell you this wild story about the original scandal where the suffix -gate comes from.

Expand full comment

I noted those parallels as the malfeasance against President Trump unfolded. Senior FBI works with barely recent intelligence asset to bring down a President. Who'd have thought it possible!

Expand full comment

It’s still worth fighting for. We must.

Expand full comment

How?

The elections and the courts are rigged.

Anyone who says or does anything is canceled and if not them then their family.

We live in East Germany.

Expand full comment

I have decided to skip the fed elections and am concentrating on my local politics. As in County and state elections. Babylon is a shitshow but staying vigilant in local politics and being present and vocal is a way. When it all collapses, the states will be the Phoenix or they won’t. It’s our last best hope Obi Wan. Also gathering aggregate news and turning off the MSM propaganda and not spending my money on woke companies or sportsball crap.

Expand full comment

Why?

Expand full comment

The threat from China is real and must be dealt with. However, I believe the greatest threat to the US is the internal threat posed by the failure of our leaders to work together to produce wise policies that unite us as a people. The "United we stand, divided we fall" axiom comes to mind.

Expand full comment

I think the greatest threat to our Republic is the success of our leaders and "representatives" in working together to erode our freedom, destroy our industrial base, undermine civil society, and promote an authoritarian view of the world as envisioned by a guy who has a bust of Lenin on his desk.

They are dividing us on purpose, because a population divided is a minimal threat to their ruling class.

Expand full comment

you left out the two precursor essentials to a viable resurgence of US power.

- reining in the entitlement state

- dealing with our debt bomb

Expand full comment

100%

Expand full comment

That's gonna be a great pitch to the electorate. "Hey Boomers and Gen Xers, have you thought about how much more war we could wage in Eurasia if y'all took a 2-3% haircut on your monthly Social Security payments?!" That sounds like an LBJ 1964 sized national electoral mandate in the making!

Expand full comment

I'd like to see us repeal 16 and 17, eliminate the immoral construct known as the income tax, phase out true Social Security (the post-65 stuff) and 95% of government offices and departments. One can dream

Expand full comment

Wow. Get rid of Social Security so that we can afford war with Russia! Sounds like a real vote getter! Want to start a new political party with me to promise it to the masses?

Expand full comment

That is not what I'm saying at all. It is unsustainable and going away regardless. and completely separate from any conflict. Nor have I ever indicated I think we should be going to war with Russia.

Expand full comment

There is nothing that can possibly unite a people that believes in lockdowns and forced masking and vaccines with a freedom loving people. America is already 2 distinct nations and wise leaders are not going to change that.

Expand full comment

I'd rather here you complain about the crotch scan at the airport.

Expand full comment

The great thing about this country is that your superiors don't have to care what you think. Now go run along to Daddy Fauci like a good boy to get your 8th booster!

Expand full comment

You complain about that? At this point it's the only action some of us get!

Expand full comment

As does “A house divided against itself cannot stand.”

Expand full comment

There was no reason for the Union and Confederacy to remain under the same roof in 1861; there is even less reason for free people to remain under the same roof with lockdowners in 2024.

Expand full comment

A significant issue is that the ideological divide does not follow state lines, but rather the urban/rural divide. There are many people, probably even a majority of actual legal voters, in "blue states" that are freedom loving Americans whose vote has not been counted in a long time.

Expand full comment

Maybe it shouldn’t stand.

Expand full comment

Amen!

Expand full comment

I think you’d enjoy reading Kurt Schlichter’s novels, which have this very theme - red America vs blue America- People’s Republic is the first book, I’ve read all 8 of them. All very entertaining yet very sobering at the same time.

Expand full comment

Ron Furgerson: Part of the "uniting problem" is that we are no longer "a people." Just look at California, where the state provides voting information in more than 18 different languages, as if understanding English is of little importance in understanding our political process. Our shared heritage, based on the founding principles and history of our country, has been blown apart, intentionally.

Expand full comment

Our current leaders want us divided. Marxist playbook. Why else tear down confederate statues?

Expand full comment

Because they hate Robert E. Lee and love Karl Marx. It really isn't as complicated as you're making it.

Expand full comment

Too bad. Bobby Lee was once second in war, second in peace and second in the hearts of his countrymen both North and South.

Expand full comment

Lee was a loser. He shoukd have listened to E. Porter Alexander and dissolved the NVA at Petersburg into numerous battalion minus sized guerilla groups.

Expand full comment

It's easy being an armchair general. I should have bought Apple when Steve Jobs returned.

Expand full comment

Well you're retarded, so it wouldn't have mattered anyway.

Expand full comment

They like shaking the jar. It keeps the ants unfocused and angry.

Expand full comment

Heer is....challenging. His fingerprints are on several bad decisions.

Two cups in, sir. Excellent read.

Expand full comment

CDR Sal, thanks for the clarity outlined in today's post.

Denial is strong in D.C. So is inertia. The smartest people in the room have led us to this ledge, and keep telling us there is nothing to see here.

We need to make sure that elected leaders (yea, that is our fault!) have access to the concepts outlined in today's post, and keep reinforcing to them that this issue is more vital to the US than the majority of policy minutiae they spend their time entangled with.

Expand full comment

How is it all our fault when elections are a farce?

Expand full comment

"Political power grows out of the barrel of a gun - Mao Tse-Tung, 1938. The 2A was a gift from our Founding Fathers. We've always had options.

Expand full comment

Amen !

Expand full comment

I'm sure China approves of armed "options." They'll support an insurgency against the federal government or for secession.

Nothing would make them happier.

Expand full comment

Nope. I don't advocate violence, but if there was a MAGA insurgency against the federal government there is no way China would support it.

Expand full comment

You are naive. Chinese and Russian social media action in the USA amplifies all wedge issues to create division.

An armed insurgency against the current US order would be a dream. They were high-fiving each other on 6 Jan 21.

Expand full comment

I don't claim to have a solution....but a large share of We the People are too easily distracted by the "news" they are fed by people that try to make sure they remain distracted. That is a topic that deserves more attention.

Add in changes to election processes added in violation of existing statute and you end up with the quicksand we seem to be stuck in.

Expand full comment

No slight on our host, but, I stopped reading when I got to the "Foreign Affairs" pull quote, "the Biden administration’s China policy has stood out as a relative bright spot." There are no bright spots in the Biden administration.

Expand full comment

Well, you missed the beauty of the forest because you saw an ant mound on the walk from the parking lot to the trailhead. Your loss.

Expand full comment

CDR: Nah. The Biden administration gets innocent people, including American servicemembers, killed. There's no parsing, here.

Expand full comment

To be fair, they have a mountain of cash coming in to their personal accounts, so that's a pretty bright spot for them.

Expand full comment

Well, this is definitley not a "read on my smart phone" substack post!

Expand full comment

well golly, CDR. THIS (and those) was worth waiting a couple of empty days for!

Expand full comment

People complained about the AI Midrats show description, saying they missed "the Old Sal" ... well ... here we go.

Expand full comment

I used to think that "Alice in Wonderland" was supposed to be a fantasy. Now it seems like it is the foreign policy guide for this administration.

Expand full comment

Hunter is the caterpillar smoking the hookah filled with cocaine.

Expand full comment

I always thought it was a math book:)

Expand full comment

I remember the old baseball Maxim: “teams play at the same level as their competition”.

We are not following the Maxim. We can’t even find our gloves.

We need a complete change of government, from the elected politicians , the selected politicians and we need to remove, with prejudice, the federal civil servants of all agencies.

Only then, can we find a Weinberger or a Lehman to clean house.

Only then, can we get to the task of building a shipyard and repair capacity and restock our magazines.

Next we need a state department devoid of its past 20 years of corruption masked as incompetence. We need to rebuild the political credibility that we have squandered with our own arrogance.

Only then, can we take China to task around the world with their unholy mafia BRI.

We need to start massive and forcibly to destroy the China presence in South America, Central America and the Caribbean.

It’s not hard to have a game plan. We simply need the willpower and we need to shit can the current political class. Time is short.

Expand full comment

Do you think we enough time to get control of 37 sane states and repeal the 16th and 17th Amendments? I really don't see any other way to restore freedom in the Republic. DC will never give up power; it must be retrieved by the states.

Expand full comment

The States need a catalyst to act.

Expand full comment

Repealing the federal government's power to tax? Ya, that will help boost the defense budget and build ships.

Expand full comment

I think Orwell was referring to the income tax which allows the fat bloated deep state to exist. Teddy R. was able to build a fleet without an income tax.

Expand full comment

We're not going back to 1900, with federal receipts at 3% of GDP. A fantasy.

Heck, the US spends 3% of GDP on defense alone.

US total tax revenue of 27% of GDP is below average in the OECD.

If you're going to fight a war, you need a strong federal government.

Expand full comment

Seems like 27% is way too much. The OECD is not my idea of a benchmark.

More fundamental is why we have to fight a war at all? I don’t see Russian battleships off Cape Ann.

Expand full comment

You have to be ready. A strong Navy is needed, in the best New England federalist tradition.

I'm not a hawk, but at some point on the continuum of the PRC taking Taiwan, or Luzon, or Singapore, you might want to fight. You would have to fight by treaty if Russia moved on Estonia or NK moved south.

As far as the OECD goes, national government isn't some new thing where there aren't tested policies which have worked out well. If Japan, Norway, Spain and the rest agree on some things they might be worth doing.

The problem with the USA is that Americans don't get much for their taxes relative to Europeans in general. Before retirement they have an additional tax known as "private medical insurance."

Expand full comment

True That:)

Expand full comment

"Spend more money" is not a sustainable option. We need to reduce 95% of spending, 100% in most areas, and use our legitimate military spending wisely. The only way to reign in the Federal government is to reduce it, and that means stop funding it.

Expand full comment

What would you cut to "reduce 95%?"

Expand full comment

entire Depts Education, Labor, HUD, HHS, eliminate income tax and most of IRS, ATF, every armed agent outside of FBI, Marshals, and Secret service, every DEI position, every DEI or Arts expenditure, grant, or other BS, every "green energy" boondoggle, majority of Justice Department, at least 50% of Homeland security across the board, repeal Patriot act and all domestic surveillance (add case by case as justified in a court of law with full congressional oversight), everything on Rand Paul's Festivus list, 80% of civilian DOD and at least 60% of GOFO, every initiative supporting the Alphabet people domestic and foreign, almost all foreign aid except where a clear national interest can be shown, eliminate all federal aid to individuals at any level (health, education, food, housing).

Obviously that's rough

Expand full comment

Pillsbury is the only guy I’ve read who openly admits that he and other “china experts” got it all wrong. The Hundred Year Marathon. Duped. Mandarin speakers. Guys who had conversions with deng xiaoping. worth the read. Wireless Wars, too. highly recommend. west sucks at identifying indirectness and understanding it. everything is taken at face value.

Expand full comment

I thought that book was excellent

Expand full comment

“China isn’t aiming for a stalemate. Neither should America.” 🎯

unfortunately i think we already have many in government and government service who are comped. for decades.

https://www.axios.com/2020/02/19/china-rating-us-governors

Expand full comment

From a link within the article: “In the Internet era . . . what is truth and what is a lie is already unimportant; what’s important is who controls discourse power.” I'd be a toad if I advocated against the 1st Amendment. So I won't. But what do you do when you can hardly get a word in edgewise or have it heard? Maybe some modern version of this? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M4ozAB3SsdI&ab_channel=JayKat7_

Expand full comment