176 Comments
Oct 25, 2023·edited Oct 25, 2023

Except for Preying Mantis and Soleimani the Iranians have acted with impunity since 1979. Why wouldn't they act now after observing our current leadership in action?

Expand full comment

Solid analysis, Professor. What to do about Iran?

Expand full comment

THEY ARE LYING TO YOU. Every war is about religion, especially in the Sandbox. Just saying...

1) They lied to u about Russia Collusion

2) They lied to u about the Ukraine War

3) They lied to u about the Ukraine Biolabs

4) They lied to u about Cov-i-d 19 Plandemic

5) They lied to u about Lockdowns

6) They lied to u about Useless Facemasks

7) They lied to u about Vaxxeens

8- They lied to u about Ivermectin

9) They lied to u about Hydroxychloroquine

10) They lied to u about Twitter Censorship

11) They lied to u about the Fake Steele Dossier

12) They lied to u about the 2020 Ele-ct-io-n

13) They lied to u about the 2022 Midterms

14) They lied to u about Hunter's Laptop

15) They lied to u about Hillary's Emails

16) They lied to u about the FBI/CIA spying on your social media

17) They lied to u about Fast & Furious

18) They lied to u about Election Interference

19) They lied to u about 9/11

20) They lied to u about Saddam & Iraq having WMDs

21) They lied to u about PizzaGate

22) They lied to u about Child S-e-x Trafficking

23) They lied to u about Epstein S-e-x Island

24) They lied to u about The Patriot Act

25) They lied to u about The Global War on Terror

26) They lied to u about The Southern Border

27) They lied to u about Jan. 6th

28) They lied to u about Vietnam

29) They lied to u about Watergate

30) They lied to u about JFK

31) They lied to u about RFK

32) They lied to u about MLK, Jr.

33) They lied to u about Benghazi

34) They lied to u about Afghanistan

35) They lied to u about The War on Drugs

36) They lied to u about HIV/AIDS

37) They lied to u about Cancer

38) They lied to u about Climate Change

39) They lied to u about The Green New Deal

40) They lied to u about Food, Water, Cleaning Products

41) They lied to u about The Federal Reserve

42) They lied to u about The Washington Act of 1871 where Congress cut a deal w/foreign powers and intl. bankers and took the $ making 10 sq. miles of DC sovereign and changed us from the Republic FOR The United States of America to the United States Corporation where we're all "citizens" w/privileges instead of rights given by God!

43) They lied to u about Mass Shootings

44) They lied to u about The Great Reset

45) They lied to u about Agenda 21

46) They lied to u about Agenda 2030

47) They lied to u about the Anthony Weiner Laptop

48) They lied to u about Wikileaks and Julian Assange

49) They lied to u about Waco

50) They lied to u about Ruby Ridge

51) They lied to u about Nashville

52) They lied to u about Las Vegas

53) They lied to u about Hollywood

54) They lied to u about the OKC Bombing

55) They lied to u about Andrew Breitbart's Death

56) They lied to u about Gold

57) They lied to u about Michael Obama

58) They lied to u about Obama's kids

59) They lied to u about Margaret Sanger

60) They lied to u about Joan Rivers' Death

61) They lied to u about Haiti

62) They lied to u about Hunter's Cocaine

63) They lied to u about Investing on Wall St.

64) They lied to u about Chinese Spy Balloons

65) They lied to u about 15min. Cities

66) They lied to u about Feminism

67) They lied to u about Antarctica

68) They lied to u about Freemasons

69) They lied to u about Operation Mockingbird

70) They lied to u about MK Ultra

71) They lied to u about Chemtrails

72) They lied to u about the Earth, Roswell, NASA, Outer Space, Moon Landing??

Anything Else?? 🤔

Expand full comment

Cringing as I type this, but have to wonder what our plan actually is. How quickly would a DDG's VLS cells be emptied shooting down drones / cruise missiles? Shudder to think we might be plinking low value targets at the expense of the ability to defend ourselves or hit the "real" target when the time comes. Iran seems to have enough media plausible deniability to keep public opinion away from ground truth, meaning we could find ourselves on the wrong end of a UN resolution condemning us for "escalation" if we hit them. Our forces will defend themselves competently (I hope and pray). We're now in the WEZ of multiple unfriendly entities, can't rule out someone deliberately targeting us to escalate and broaden the conflict. Looking for candidates to do that produces a long list with little or no effort.

Expand full comment

Ike will stay in the Med and Ford to the Persian Gulf? Opposite of all I've been hearing. Has there been a change?

Expand full comment
Oct 25, 2023·edited Oct 25, 2023

I'd vote for this - a threat to sink every ship in the Iranian Navy if the hostages aren't released by X, and X means soon. You hit Iran where you can't hurt civilians, who despise their regime, so you reduce the risk of turning the civilians against us. Even as small as it is, their Navy is still an important asset to the regime. Hitting back at proxies - what does this do?

Heck, end an Iranian Air Force base for all I care. But take out an asset that matters to Iran. The proxies are useful idiots to the Mullahs. And sacrificial lambs.

Expand full comment

The problem I see is that Netanyahu is tied to attacking Iran and the Arab world will see us as agents of Israel. Self defense is fine but anything else will boomerang on us

Expand full comment

"Last week we deployed UK based F-15E Strike Eagles to Jordan. That is clearly designed to deter Hezbollah in Lebanon and perhaps as part of possible action against Gaza"

Why Jordan? Because it would be a stronger message if we based in Israel?

Doesn't Jordan basing either limit our response options or risk widening the conflict?

Expand full comment

The US and Iran have been in a DeFacto State of War since November 1979. The Iranians have bombed US Embassies and military Installations throughout the Middle East, attacked US Forces in Iraq and Kurdistan during OIF, OIR. This list goes on.

The only time the Iranians backed down was when the Vincennes took out Iran Air 655. Good ol Robocruiser.

I've discussed with some IC Friends about why now, the Iranians seem really intent on provoking a US Military response in the region. Power Struggle in Tehran among the Hard Liners and Ultra Hard Liners in the Guardian Council? Did the Iranians develop a Nuke or obtain a Nuke from the North Koreans?

If the proverbial Balloon goes up in the Middle East with an Iranian attack in the region, even if the US moderates their response, you can be sure the Israelis wont.

Expand full comment

Minor correction: CARNEY has been back in Mayport since 2020. ROOSEVELT is a Rota ship detached to the FORD CSG.

Expand full comment

There's also the ~500 Americans that live/reside in Gaza that Hamas is refusing to allow to leave - American human shields.

Expand full comment
Oct 25, 2023·edited Oct 25, 2023

> None of this would happen without Iran’s backing, money, weapons, and larger network of proxies that all form different fingers of a fist aimed at Israel.

And none of this would happen without America's backing, money, larger weapons, and smaller network of proxies directed at Tehran!

/s

Look, all the support we give the IDF, and yet still they take their orders from Bibi, not Biden. We cajole, not control; we have influence but it's not unlimited.

Forget that Iran deals with the same complexities in it's relationship with Hamas, and that invites miscalculation.

Which gets to my real beef with "none of this would happen" as a claim. If the President of the United States and the Supreme Leader of Iran met and made an agreement for both to simply withdraw from the whole Israel/Palestine conflict—and both those leaders referred the agreement their respective democratic assemblies—and both those assemblies ratified the agreement, which became a treaty—and both sides honored the treaty—if all those things happened, this would still be happening!

In fact, what does the front porch think is more achievable? The things I've described? Or bringing peace to the Holy Land?

Expand full comment

BZ to the CARNEY CIC team. The last time that a DDG 51 Class CIC team was in the news was when CIC was used as a secondary ship's head.

Expand full comment

If we're really serious, splash the next Iranian boat that harasses our ships entering the PG.

Expand full comment

What every reader of this blog should do is sit down and put pen to paper and write your Congressman. Tell him how proud you are of the Navy's response to the war, and DEMAND THAT HE FUND THE CONSTRUCTION OF MORE SHIPS LIKE THE ONE THAT SHOT DOWN IRAN'S MISSILES.

Somebody put it better than I did, and I think he wrote that we should "build TICOs until the cows come home." That asset has shown value, now is the time to press for more of them.

Expand full comment

Oh goody, time for another round of the Middle East version of the game "Proxie Whack-a-Mole." So rather than darting here and fro plinking terrorists with Hellfire missiles, this time we will be all about plinking slow moving drones and cheap cruise missiles with expensive anti-air missiles. Perhaps this will avail us of an opportunity to lower the transaction costs of dealing with this garbage rather than employing SM-2's.

Expand full comment